Identity Politics, Identity Poetics – The Meanings of Authorship in the Films No Mercy, The Long Road to the Director’s Chair, and Sirens Call
Elina Andelin, editor-in-chief of Lilat-zine and a doctoral researcher in philosophy, reflects on women’s and queer authorship, as well as the corporeality of identities, in relation to the DocPoint programme films No Mercy, The Long Road to the Director’s Chair, and Sirens Call.
Why do we need art created by women and queer people? This question arises as I watch the documentary films No Mercy (2025), The Long Road to the Director’s Chair (2025), and Sirens Call (2025).
Directed by Isa Willinger, No Mercy explores Ukrainian filmmaker Kira Muratova’s claim that women make more extreme films than men. The documentary gives voice to women and queer directors who examine cinema’s capacity to dismantle power, violence, and desire. The Long Road to the Director’s Chair, directed by Vibeke Løkkeberg, documents a women’s film seminar held in West Berlin in 1973. Long thought lost for fifty years, the recovered material captures the feminist film movement’s efforts to radically transform the film industry. Sirens Call, directed by Miriam Gossing and Lina Sieckmann, portrays members of the merfolk subculture in the United States during the Trump era.
The films demonstrate that what is being said cannot be fully separated from who is speaking; diversity among creators is a prerequisite for diversity in subjects, perspectives, and modes of expression. This message is particularly timely in an era in which scepticism towards identity politics permeates both right-wing and left-wing political discourse.
Lived Identities
Before examining the films in greater detail, I want to pause to reflect on the significance of the artist’s identity. Identities are sometimes discussed as if they were abstract and detached from the world. Approached from a phenomenological perspective, however, identities can be understood as embodied and grounded in the world.
The identity of the subject can be understood through the phenomenological concept of style. Style refers to a mode of embodied being that manifests itself in all of the subject’s actions. It is formed through life experiences sedimented in the body, which shape our habits, dispositions, and possibilities for action. Through style, everything we do expresses our life history and lived perspective – whether in subtle gestures or in creative production (Merleau-Ponty 1945/2012, 87–89, 131–132, 143–145, 414).
Philosopher Sara Heinämaa has argued that gender identity should be understood through the concept of style: it is a modality of being-in-the-world and of relating to others that does not describe what we are, but how we are (Heinämaa 2003, 67–69). In my view, the same analysis can be extended to other class-based identities as well. They are embodied without being physiological, and they articulate the sedimentations of our lived lives, the possibilities available to us, our relations to others, and the perspective from which the world appears to us.
A phenomenological conception of identity also has implications for how authorship is understood. According to Maurice Merleau-Ponty, the visual arts do not aim at objective truth; rather, the artist’s concern is the world as it appears in their experience. In art, the one who sees and that which is seen merge into an inseparable whole (Merleau-Ponty 1964/2012, 428–434). This analysis can also be extended to cinema. Because art is created by an embodied subject, the artist’s bodily mode of being and the life history sedimented in the body shape the perspective expressed in their work. As a result, the artist’s identity becomes inextricably intertwined with their artistic output.
The Return of the Author
Literary scholar Roland Barthes declared the author dead in the 1960s (Barthes 1967/1977), and the separation of authorship from art has since become a dominant premise in the study of the arts. However, minority authors have long tried to revive the author. As Kristina Bausse argues, questions related to authorship were defined as irrelevant before, for example, women had even reached the position of author – let alone made their own contribution to the discussion of authorship (Bausse 2013, 54–55).
If we assume a universal, disembodied, and ahistorical subject, it may indeed be easy to proclaim the author dead. If, however, we understand the subject as always living within a specific historical situation and from a particular embodied mode of being, authorship remains a fundamentally important question.

Still from the film The Long Road to the Director’s Chair. Vibeke Løkkeberg pictured front right. Photo: Abisag Tüllmann.
From In Front of the Camera to Behind It
The documentaries No Mercy and The Long Road to the Director’s Chair consist largely of interviews with women and queer filmmakers, painting a picture of the ways in which women’s entry into filmmaking has changed the industry.
Perhaps the most obvious level at which women’s and queer authorship is visible in art is in the subject matter. Documentary filmmakers have pioneered films that examine themes from their own lives. Topics that male directors have overlooked, such as abortion and sexual violence, are highlighted in their work.
However, the identity of the author does not primarily determine the topics covered, but rather colours the perspective taken on them. No Mercy focuses specifically on films that are considered “violent”. This often means films that depict violence and sexuality. The documentary does not stop at the level of subject matter, but examines the thematics of the gaze. What makes films made by women appear violent is not only that they depict subordination, but also that their subjects are portrayed from an oppressed perspective. Even when men make films about women, women are usually not the subjects of the films, but the objects of the gaze.
The Male Gaze
Film director Nina Menkes says in No Mercy: “The male gaze is the law of cinema.” Laura Mulvey’s concept of the male gaze describes a hegemonic way of looking, in which women are passive erotic objects, displayed for male viewers. Under the male gaze, gender-subordinated characters cannot be at the centre of the action, but are passive experiencers of events brought about by men (Mulvey 1975/2014, 413–414).
Our entire media landscape is so saturated with the aestheticisation of the objectification of women and queer people that we have become numb to it. Men constantly make films that depict gendered subjugation without it being shocking. When violence is depicted from a subordinate perspective, the reception is different. In No Mercy, Nina Menkes discusses the shock caused by her film Magdalena Viraga (1986). Male audiences accused the film of being excessively violent and obscene. According to Menkes, however, only the woman’s face is shown in the film’s numerous sex scenes. It seems that focusing on the subordinate subject’s world of experience is what is perceived as shocking.
When we understand identities as embodied layers of life histories, it becomes clear why cisgender men and gender-minoritised people often portray sex and violence differently. For cisgender men, sex is a field of privilege – for women and queer people, it is one of the central scenes of oppression and humiliation. Because gender so strongly shapes lived experience, it colours the perspective taken on sexuality. Violence also manifests itself differently for marginalised subjects. White cisgender male creators may portray violence as a triumphant act through which the individual gains power. If, on the other hand, the creator has personally experienced oppressive violence or lived in fear of it, the perspective is often different.
Of course, gender-minoritised creators can also imitate the male gaze and reproduce its norms. We are all familiar with the language of the male gaze because it defines our media imagery. Nevertheless, women and queer people have a particular opportunity to challenge gendered power, because only they fully understand how insidiously it constricts its subjects and limits their living space.
Freedom for Me or for Everyone
When a person marginalised on the basis of gender moves from in front of the camera to behind it, this change of position is undoubtedly liberating. However, this liberation does not necessarily extend to those who continue to work in front of the camera or elsewhere behind the scenes.
The feminist filmmakers featured in The Long Road to the Director’s Chair emphasise a collective and democratic approach to filmmaking that dismantles the myth of the male genius and the director’s dominance. At the same time, they highlight women who advance in male hierarchies by turning their backs on other women. Some secure a place at the table by adopting the rules of male-dominated structures. “We don’t want to be just bad copies of men,” says one feminist working in the film industry.
Instead of genuine empowerment, even members of minorities can seize power by subjugating others. A telling example is director Catharine Breillat, interviewed in No Mercy. Caroline Ducey, the lead actor in one of Breillat’s most famous films, has made serious allegations of abuse during filming (Kohn 2022). If women and queer people abandon solidarity once they gain power, no structural change will take place.
A Kaleidoscope of Gazes
Nina Menkes asks in No Mercy what remains when a filmmaker rejects both the male gaze and conventional narratives assigned to women. The question is rhetorical. Menkes argues that we do not yet know the answer, because the industry remains deeply male-dominated.
However, independent films, especially those made by women and queer people, already offer answers. Rather than producing a new hegemonic gaze, such as a “female gaze”, they present a kaleidoscope of perspectives, each capable of conveying universal meanings. Stories told from the perspective of white cisgender men are typically seen as universal, while marginalised experiences are pushed to the margins of humanity.

Still from the film Sirens Call.
Marginal and Universal
Sirens Call can be seen as a response to Menkes’ question. Directed by two queer women, this sci-fi documentary hybrid shows how the marginal can be made universal. It offers a powerful demonstration of the claims made by No Mercy and The Long Road to the Director’s Chair about the transformative potential of women’s and queer authorship.
The film approaches its subjects with remarkable respect and sensitivity. In other hands, people who are easily ridiculed or questioned are allowed to become icons of universal experience. The camera elevates its marginalised subjects, presenting them as luminous and mythic figures.
Rather than imposing an outsider’s perspective, Sirens Call immerses the viewer in the lived world of its protagonist, Una. Half human and half merfolk, she inhabits two worlds without fully belonging to either. The world is presented as it appears to her. Her reality is never questioned, but rendered so coherent that only the most hardened viewer could resist entering it.
There is little dialogue, but by following Una through shopping malls, sterile hotel rooms, and crowded streets, the camera conveys her outsider status and alienation with striking intensity.
Sirens Call is queer not only in its themes, but above all in its perspective. Othered subjects become the centre of its universe. Una’s hyper-specific experience reveals profound truths about community, authenticity, and identity. Anyone who has experienced otherness can recognise themselves in her words: “It’s not a question of whether you live in the ‘real’ world, but whose version of the real world you want to live in.”
The film portrays its subjects as they wish to be seen. It thus demonstrates the empowering potential of the cinematic gaze. Visual communication designer Nina Andelin argues that when portraying marginalised experiences, one should ask not only whether they are depicted positively or negatively, but whether the experiencer is also an active participant in constructing the image. In such cases, images can function as testimony, capable of healing the wounds of marginalisation (Andelin 2023, 36, 65–85).
Sirens Call is a refreshing balm not only for Una’s parched skin, but also for the fractured hearts of marginalised viewers. It is an unapologetic celebration of writing one’s own story and making one’s world visible. I dare say that a white cisgender man could not have made this film.
Material Identities
In recent years, parts of the contemporary left have turned away from identity politics. Emphasising identity groups is said to create division and distract from shared concerns. Identities and material structures are thus pitted against one another. However, identity groups such as gender, racialisation, and sexual orientation are themselves material structures that shape our lives in tangible ways.
The films discussed here show that identities are not merely linguistic constructions, but embodied ways of being in the world.
The concept of identity politics originates with the Combahee River Collective. It refers to political action grounded in lived experience of oppression. Identity politics means recognising overlapping forms of domination and organising collectively against them. As the Collective writes: “We realised that the only people who care enough about us to work tirelessly for our liberation are ourselves” (Combahee River Collective 1979/2019, 31).
Identity politics is not about fragmenting politics into individual identities, but about recognising the collective political power of marginalised groups.
No Mercy, The Long Road to the Director’s Chair, and Sirens Call show that the inclusion of women and queer people in filmmaking changes not only who makes films, but also how films are made and what kinds of cultures develop behind the scenes. When gender-minoritised people take hold of the camera themselves, an industry saturated with the male gaze begins to crack. Inclusion transforms material structures by bringing embodied knowledge of power and resistance into creative practice.
Elina Andelin
Elina Andelin (@elinaandelin) is a doctoral researcher in philosophy and editor-in-chief of the lesbian/feminist micro-zine Lilat (@lilat.zine). Her doctoral research examines experiences of violence from a phenomenological perspective of the body. She is interested in the intersections of research, art, and political action.
Films
Gossing, M. & Sieckmann, L. (director). 2025. Sirens Call. filmfaust.
Løkkeberg, V. (director). 2025. The Long Road to the Director’s Chair. The Norway Film Development, Viafilm.
Willinger, I. (director). 2025. No Mercy. Tondowski Films.
Literature
Andelin (ent. Grönlund), N. 2023. Visual testimonies: Addressing lived experiences of adversity in visual communication design and art direction. [Maisterintutkielma, Aalto-yliopisto]. Aaltodoc.
Barthes, R. 1967/1977. “The Death of the Author”. Teoksessa Image Music Text. Kääntänyt S. Heath. Fontana Press.
Bausse, K. “The Return of the Author Ethos and Identity Politics”. Teoksessa E. Gray & D. Johnson (toim.). Companion to Media Authorship. Blackwell, 48–68.
Combahee River Collective. 1979/2019. “A Black Feminist Statement”. Monthly Review 70(8), 29–36.
Heinämaa, S. 2003. Toward a Phenomenology of Sexual Difference. Rowman & Littlefield.
Kohn, E. 2022. “Catherine Breillat Says ‘Actors Are Prostitutes’ as Her ‘Romance’ Star Confronts the Scene That Went Too Far”. IndieWire, published 14.2.2022.
Lahtinen, V. 2019. ”Olin sosiaalisen oikeudenmukaisuuden soturi – kunnes halusin lopettaa sotimisen”. Helsingin Sanomat, published 26.8.2019.
Merleau-Ponty, M. 1943/2012. Phenomenology of Perception. Translated by D. Landes. Routledge.
Merleau-Ponty, M. 1961/2012. ”Silmä ja henki”. Teoksessa Filosofisia kirjoituksia. Edited and translated by M. Luoto & T. Roinila. Nemo, 415–477.
Mulvey, L. 1975/2014. ”Visual Pleasures and Narrative Cinema”. In S. MacKenzie (toim.). Film Manifestos and Global Cinema Cultures. University of California Press, 409–423.
Vuorinen, P. 2021. ”Politiikan tiivistäminen identiteettipolitiikaksi vie kyvyn analysoida politiikan ydintä”. Kansan uutiset, published 29.3.2021.




