DocFokus: Science under threat – A conversation on the role of scientists and the media in the Post-Truth Era

On Wednesday evening, 4 February, at the Kino Regina theatre in the Oodi Library, journalists Mari Manninen and Adile Sevimli, along with researcher and non-fiction novelist Tiina Raevaara, gathered to share their initial impressions of the film Blame, which had been screened earlier, and to discuss the highly relevant  issue of the status of scientists and journalists in the post-truth era. The event, organized together by the Union of Journalists in Finland and DocPoint, was moderated by the Union’s International Affairs Specialist, Salla Nazarenko.

The term post-truth era came into wider use in the mid-2010s in the Anglo-Saxon world, driven by the rise to power of Donald Trump and the Brexit campaign. The post-truth era is related to political circumstances in which appealing to the sentiments of the audience increasingly takes precedence over facts in order to achieve certain political objectives. A compelling narrative becomes more important than truth itself. Key characteristics of the post-truth era include the deliberate weakening of the authority of the scientific community and the rise of social media influencers as opinion makers.

The post-truth era is also marked by the fragmentation of the media ecosystem, where traditional news outlets are forced to compete for the attention of the audience. This development, in which the audience has an increasing ability to choose a narrative that suits and reinforces their predetermined beliefs, intensifies polarization in society.

However, journalist and non-fiction novelist Mari Manninen sees opportunities in the cooperation between professional journalists and news influencers that could benefit both parties. She highlights that journalists have a lot to learn from influencers in how they connect with their audience, while influencers, for their part, have much to learn from journalists about the ethical aspects of newsmaking and the importance of conducting fact-checks — both of which are currently lacking in social media work culture.

Raevaara points out that scientists are expected to be active on social media and participate in societal conversations, even as the atmosphere becomes increasingly hostile to such efforts. She is also calling for a more proactive stance from the media to assist and cover some of the points made in the inform Situation of Academic Freedom in Finland, such as the intensifying restrictive procedures within scientific institutions themselves. 

She also draws attention to how, during the covid pandemic, science was used to enforce geopolitical prejudices and create political frontlines. One example of these practices was the emphasis on the theory of the virus escaping from the laboratory, so strongly that the rationale of biodiversity loss was set aside—mainly because the former better served political objectives and provided the audience with an easier explanation that sidelined the complexity of self-enforcing developments.

The conversationalists agree that the pandemic offers the media an opportunity to re-evaluate their procedures. In the most tense moments of the pandemic, the media seemed to forget its role as the watchdog of power and limited itself to repeating the narrative of the governments without criticism. Manninen highlights the importance of the media distancing itself from the hectic flow of information and trying to rise above the situation in order to see the bigger picture. Raevaara hopes that the media will find ways to communicate to the audience the nature of science as an ever-evolving and ever-changing entity.

Journalists and scientists are in the same boat: both face the challenges of social media and are driven by the goal of providing the audience with accurate and reliable information. The freedom of speech is a core value for both. 

Whatever the challenges may be, Sevimli sees a clear need for slower, more thoughtful media. She also reminds us that the challenges brought by the post-truth era are not ones that scientists and journalists tackle alone.

The film Blame, was part of the themed series Backed by Science, portrays the challenges scientists face under the pressure of headline journalism and a hardening political atmosphere.

Nina Moberg

Photo: Merja Siljamäki

DocFokus discussions are public, free discussions on current topics. The discussions have been part of DocPoint’s programme for several years. In the 2026 festival, there were two DocFokus discussions.